diff --git a/docs/README.md b/docs/README.md
index 5e79a02..3cd6f4f 100644
--- a/docs/README.md
+++ b/docs/README.md
@@ -572,7 +572,9 @@ _WARNING_: HSTS will force your users to visit the HTTPS version of your site fo
 
 ### Missing Certificate
 
-If HTTPS is enabled for a virtual host but its certificate is missing, nginx-proxy will configure nginx to use the default certificate (`default.crt` with `default.key`) and return a 500 error.
+If no matching certificate is found for a given virtual host, nginx-proxy will:
+* configure nginx to use the default certificate (`default.crt` with `default.key`) and return a 500 error for HTTPS,
+* force enable HTTP; i.e. `HTTPS_METHOD` will switch to `noredirect` if it was set to `nohttp` or `redirect`.
 
 If the default certificate is also missing, nginx-proxy will configure nginx to accept HTTPS connections but fail the TLS negotiation. Client browsers will render a TLS error page. As of March 2023, web browsers display the following error messages:
 
diff --git a/nginx.tmpl b/nginx.tmpl
index 86f001f..b3a6011 100644
--- a/nginx.tmpl
+++ b/nginx.tmpl
@@ -590,6 +590,10 @@ proxy_set_header Proxy "";
 
     {{- $default := eq $globals.Env.DEFAULT_HOST $hostname }}
     {{- $https_method := or (first (groupByKeys $vhost_containers "Env.HTTPS_METHOD")) $globals.Env.HTTPS_METHOD "redirect" }}
+    {{- /* When the certificate is missing we want to ensure that HTTP is enabled; hence switching from 'nohttp' or 'redirect' to 'noredirect' */}}
+    {{- if (and (not $cert_ok) (or (eq $https_method "nohttp") (eq $https_method "redirect"))) }}
+        {{- $https_method = "noredirect" }}
+    {{- end }}
     {{- $http2_enabled := parseBool (or (first (keys (groupByLabel $vhost_containers "com.github.nginx-proxy.nginx-proxy.http2.enable"))) $globals.Env.ENABLE_HTTP2 "true")}}
     {{- $http3_enabled := parseBool (or (first (keys (groupByLabel $vhost_containers "com.github.nginx-proxy.nginx-proxy.http3.enable"))) $globals.Env.ENABLE_HTTP3 "false")}}
 
@@ -642,7 +646,7 @@ proxy_set_header Proxy "";
     {{- $default_https_exists := false }}
     {{- $http3_enabled := false }}
     {{- range $vhost := $globals.vhosts }}
-        {{- $http := or (ne $vhost.https_method "nohttp") (not $vhost.cert_ok) }}
+        {{- $http := ne $vhost.https_method "nohttp" }}
         {{- $https := ne $vhost.https_method "nohttps" }}
         {{- $http_exists = or $http_exists $http }}
         {{- $https_exists = or $https_exists $https }}
@@ -725,7 +729,7 @@ server {
         {{ template "upstream" (dict "globals" $globals "Path" $path "VPath" $vpath) }}
     {{- end }}
 
-    {{- if and $vhost.cert_ok (eq $vhost.https_method "redirect") }}
+    {{- if (eq $vhost.https_method "redirect") }}
 server {
     server_name {{ $hostname }};
         {{- if $vhost.server_tokens }}
@@ -766,7 +770,7 @@ server {
     {{- if $vhost.http2_enabled }}
     http2 on;
     {{- end }}
-    {{- if or (eq $vhost.https_method "nohttps") (not $vhost.cert_ok) (eq $vhost.https_method "noredirect") }}
+    {{- if or (eq $vhost.https_method "nohttps") (eq $vhost.https_method "noredirect") }}
     listen {{ $globals.external_http_port }} {{ $default_server }};
         {{- if $globals.enable_ipv6 }}
     listen [::]:{{ $globals.external_http_port }} {{ $default_server }};