* tests(fix): Increase some timeouts
Running tests locally via a VM these tests would fail sometimes due to the time from being queued and Amavis actually processing being roughly around 30 seconds.
There should be no harm in raising this to 60 seconds, other than delaying a failure case which will ripple through other time sensitive tests.
It's better to pass when functionality is actually correct but just needs a bit longer to complete.
* tests(fix): Don't setup an invalid hostname
During container startup `helpers/dns.sh` would panic with `hostname -f` failing.
Dropping `--domainname` for this container is fine and does not affect the point of it's test.
---
It's unclear why this does not occur in CI. Possibly changes within the docker daemon since as CI runs docker on Ubuntu 20.04? (2020).
For clarity, this may be equivalent to setting a hostname of `domain.com.domain.com`, or `--hostname` value truncated the NIS domain (`--domainname`) of the same value.
IIRC, it would still fail with both options using different values if `--hostname` was multi-label. I believe I've documented how non-deterministic these options can be across different environments.
`--hostname` should be preferred. There doesn't seem to be any reason to actually need `--domainname` (which is NIS domain name, unrelated to the DNS domain name). We still need to properly investigate reworking our ENV support that `dns.sh` manages.
---
Containers were also not removing themselves after failures either (missing teardown). Which would cause problems when running tests again.
* chore: Normalize white-space
Sets a consistent indent size of 2 spaces. Previously this varied a fair bit, sometimes with tabs or mixed tabs and spaces.
Some formatting with blank lines.
Easier to review with white-space in diff ignored. Some minor edits besides blank lines, but no change in functionality.
* fix: `setup.sh` target container under test
Some of the `setup.sh` commands did not specify the container which was problematic if another `docker-mailserver` container was running, causing test failures.
This probably doesn't help with `test/no_container.bats`, but at least prevents `test/tests.bats` failing at this point.
* refactored `check-for-changes.sh`
I refactored `check-for-changes.sh` and used the new log. `_notify` can
therefore be deleted as it is used no more.
I opted to source `/etc/dms-settings` as a whole to
future-proof the script. When the DNS adjustments PRs (that do not exist
by now but will exit in the future) are done, we can then remove
`_obtain_hostname_and_domainname` because we're already writing the
variables to `/etc/dms-settings`. I left instructions in the script in
the form of TODO comments.
Because we now log the date for all messages of the changedetector, we
need to `tail` a bit more log than before.
* chore(refactor): DRY up the `_setup_ssl` method
- `/etc/postfix/ssl` was a bit misleading in usage here. As a maintainer (of my own contribution!) I was confused why only `/etc/postfix/ssl` was referenced and not `/etc/dovecot/ssl`.
- The postfix specific path is unnecessary, dovecot was referencing it via it's config, the same can be done from postfix to a generic DMS specific config location instead.
- This location is defined and created early as `/etc/dms/tls` (with var `DMS_TLS_PATH`). All usage of `/etc/postfix/ssl` has been replaced, making it easier to grok. Several `mkdir` commands related to this have been dropped as a result.
- Likewise, a related `TMP_DMS_TLS_PATH` var provides a reference to the config volume path `/tmp/docker-mailserver` which is used for conditions on presently hard-coded paths.
- Other values that benefit from being DRY have been lifted up into vars. Definitely easier to follow now and makes some further opportunities clearer to tackle in a future refactor.
- `chmod` has been updated where appropriate. Public key/cert is acceptable to have as readable by non-root users (644). The custom type with single fullchain file was not root accessible only, but should as it contains a private key.
- That said, the security benefit can be a bit moot due to source files that were copied remain present, the user would be responsible to ensure similar permissions on their source files.
- I've not touched LetsEncrypt section as I don't have time to investigate into that yet (not familiar with that portion).
---
* chore: Remove mkcert logic and dovecot cert
- No longer serving a purpose.
- Our own TLS startup script handles a variety of cert scenarios, while the dropped code was always generating a self-signed cert and persisting an unused cert regardless with `ONE_DIR=1`.
- To avoid similar issues that DH params had with doveadm validating filepath values in the SSL config, the default dummy values match postfix pointing to "snakeoil" cert. That serves the same purpose as mkcert was covering in the image.
- Bonus, no more hassle with differing mkcert target paths for users replacing our supplied Dovecot with the latest community edition.
---
* Error handling for SSL_TYPE
- Added a panic utility to exit early when SSL_TYPE conditions are misconfigured.
- Some info text had order of key/cert occurrence swapped to be consistent with key then cert.
- Some existing comments moved and rephrased.
- Additional comments added.
- `-f` test for cert files instead of `-e` (true also for directories/devices/symlinks).
- _notify messages lifted out of conditionals so that they always output when the case is hit.
- ~~Empty SSL_TYPE collapsed into catch all panic, while it's contents is now mapped to a new 'disabled' value.~~
---
* Use sedfile + improve sed expressions + update case style
- Uses sedfile when appropriate (file change intentional, not optional match/check).
- sed expressions modified to be DRY and reduce escaping via `-r` flag (acceptable if actual text content contains no `?`,`+`,`()` or `{}` characters, [otherwise they must be escaped](https://www.gnu.org/software/sed/manual/html_node/Extended-regexps.html)).
- sed captures anything matched between the parenthesis`()` and inserts it via `\1` as part of the replacement.
- case statements adopt the `(` prefix, adopting recent shell style for consistency.
---
* Refactor SSL_TYPE=disabled
- Postfix is also disabled now.
- Included heavy inline documentation reference for maintainers.
- Dropped an obsolete postfix config option 'use_tls' on the relayhost function, it was replaced by 'security_level'.
---
* I'm a friggin' sed wizard now
- The `modern` TLS_LEVEL is the default values for the configs they modify. As such, `sedfile` outputs an "Error" which isn't an actual concern, back to regular `sed`.
- I realized that multiple edits for the same file can all be done at once via `-e` (assuming other sed options are the same for each operation), and that `g` suffix is global scope for single line match, not whole file (default as sed iterates through individual lines).
- Some postfix replacements have `smtp` and `smtpd` lines, collapsed into a single `smtpd?` instead now that I know sed better.
---
* tests(fix): Tests that require SSL/TLS to pass
- SSL_TYPE=snakeoil added as temporary workaround.
- nmap tests are being dropped. These were added about 4-5 years ago, I have since made these redundant with the `testssl.sh` tests.
- Additionally the `--link` option is deprecated and IIRC these grades were a bit misleading when I initially used nmap in my own TLS cipher suite update PRs in the past.
- The removed SSL test is already handled in mail_ssl_manual.bats
ldap test:
- Replace `--link` alias option with `--network` and alias assignment.
- Parameterized some values and added the `SSL_TYPE` to resolve the starttls test failure.
privacy test:
- Also needed `SSL_TYPE` to pass the starttls test.
`tests.bats` had another starttls test for imap:
- Workaround for now is to give the main test container `SSL_TYPE=snakeoil`.
---
* Remove the expired lets-encrypt cert
This expired in March 2021. It was originally required when first added back in 2016 as LetsEncrypt was fairly new and not as broadly accepted into OS trust stores.
No longer the case today.
---
* chore: Housekeeping
Not required for this PR branch, little bit of tidying up while working on these two test files.
- privacy test copied over content when extracted from `tests.bats` that isn't relevant.
- ldap test was not as easy to identify the source of DOVECOT_TLS. Added comment to make the prefix connection to `configomat.sh` and `.ext` files more easier to find.
- Additionally converted the two localhost FQDN to vars.
---
* Default SSL_TYPE becomes `''` (aka equivalent to desired `disabled` case)
- This is to prevent other tests from failing by hitting the panic catchall case.
- More ideal would be adjusting tests to default to `disabled`, rather than treating `disabled` as an empty / unset SSL_TYPE value.
---
* Add inline documentation for `dms_panic`
- This could later be better formatted and placed into contributor docs.
Panic with kill (shutdown) not exit (errex):
- `kill 1` from `_shutdown` will send SIGTERM signal to PID 1 (init process).
- `exit 1` within the `start-mailserver.sh` init scripts context, will just exit the initialization script leaving the container running when it shouldn't.
The two previous `_shutdown` methods can benefit from using `dms_panic` wrapper instead to standardize on panic messages.
* feat: Change Postfix smtpd_tls key and cert files to chain_files
Since Postfix 3.4, `smtpd_tls_cert_file` and `smtpd_tls_key_file` have been deprecated in favor of `smtpd_tls_chain_files` which supports a list of values where a single or sequence of file paths provide a private key followed by it's certificate chain.
* feat: Dual certificate support
`smtpd_tls_chain_files` allows for multiple key+cert bundles so that you can provide different key types, such as ECDSA and RSA.
To maintain compatibility with the current CERT/KEY ENV vars only a 2nd certificate is supported.
Since Dovecot 2.2.31 a related feature is also available, but it is limited to only providing one alternative certificate via separate cert and key settings.
---
This feature enables support for multiple certificates, eg for serving modern ECDSA certs with RSA as fallback.
* chore: Refactor variable names to meet style guide
Improved some comments too.
* chore: Have function definitions respect style guide
* chore: Minor edits to comments
* chore: Expand on comments for maintenance, alert of insecure config
When `SSL_TYPE` isn't properly setup, we're still offering SSL connections but not warning in logs about the insecurity of such, or why a misconfiguration may have occurred.
This commit more clearly communicates to the user that they should look into the issue before considering deploying to production.
The `TODO` comments communicate to any future maintainer to consider treating these improper configs as disabling TLS instead.
* fix: Use `snakeoil` cert
I mistakenly thought this was placeholder text, which broke some tests. This adds the two files in the correct order (private key followed by cert/chain), to fix that issue.
* fix: Disable alt cert for Dovecot if necessary
Certain scenarios may persist state of previously configured alt cert via ENV vars that are removed from a future run. If the config is not reset to original immutable state, this will correctly disable the config from using alt cert unintentionally.
* fix: Satisfy ShellCheck lint
By switching from string var to array / list expansion, this better stores the extracted result and applies it in a manner that ShellCheck linting approves, removing the need to disable the rule.
* feat: Support dual cert test
Few tweaks to the test script allows re-purposing it for covering dual cert support as well.
* chore: Rearranged cert and key lines
A little reorganization, mostly placing private key ahead of related cert lines.
* chore: Refactor `_set_certificate`
This should make the parameters a little less confusing.
Previously was 3 parameters, but the Postfix parameter (1st) may look like two variables if you don't pay attention to the surrounding quotes; while the Dovecot parameters (2nd + 3rd) would have an opposing order. There was also a variant where the `FULLKEYCHAIN` var was passed in three times.
Now it's two params, with the 2nd param as an optional one. If the 2nd param is provided, then the two params are in the order of private key then certificate, otherwise if only a single parameter it's a single PEM file with the full cert chain and private key bundled.
This avoids implying that Postfix and Dovecot might use different files.
* chore: Document current state of `SSL_TYPE` logic better
Inlined for the benefit of anyone else maintaining this section if I'm unable to address the concerns within my own time.
* docs: ENV vars
`TLS_LEVEL=old` isn't in the codebase anymore, not likely to be relevant to retain.
No point in documenting what is considered invalid / unsupported config value in the first place for `SSL_TYPE`.
`SSL_TYPE=manual` was missing documentation for both related file path ENV vars, they've been added along with their alt fallback variants.
* chore: Update Dovecot LMTP SSL test config
Not sure how relevant this is, the file isn't complete sync with the main dovecot `10-ssl.conf` config, adding the support just in case.
* chore: Rename `FULLKEYCHAIN` to avoid confusion
There doesn't appear to be a standardized name for this type of file bundle, and `keychain` may be misleading (fullkeychain often provides macOS keychain results on search engines).
Opting for a more explicit `KEY_WITH_FULLCHAIN` name instead.
* fix: Invalid var name
`_set_certificate` refactor commit accidentally changed a var name and committed that breaking the dual cert support (thanks tests!).
* test: Refactor `mail_ssl_manual.bats`
Proper test return values instead of `wc -l` based checking.
Tests with dual cert support active, tests that feature (to better detect failure case.
Third test case was unable to verify new self-signed certificate, added new certs signed with self-signed root CA.
Adjusted openssl `CApath` parameter to use `CAfile` instead as `letsencrypt` cert was replaced thus CA cert is missing from the system trust store.
* test: Properly check for files in `mail_ssl_manual.bats`
Fixes lint error.
Also realized I was accidentally asserting a file exists in the test environment, not within the container.
Resolved that and also added an additional test case to ensure the ENV var files are valid when passed in, in the event a change misconfigures them and that the issue is identified earlier.
* chore: Apply PR review feedback
Better format some strings that had mixed quotes when they weren't necessary.
Additionally DRYed up the config path for Postfix and Dovecot within the `_setup_ssl` method.
Co-authored-by: Georg Lauterbach <infrastructure@itbsd.com>
