diff --git a/castero/menu.py b/castero/menu.py
index f8d6693..32b049c 100644
--- a/castero/menu.py
+++ b/castero/menu.py
@@ -128,7 +128,7 @@ class Menu(ABC):
             if self._active:
                 attr = curses.color_pair(2)
             else:
-                attr = curses.color_pair(3)
+                attr = curses.color_pair(4)
         else:
             attr = attr | item['attr']